Sally Tribe
This article was originally published as a two-part series in CBT Today magazine, February & May 2024
When you think about the perimenopause and menopause what images come to mind? Is it middle-aged women fanning themselves and saying they are feeling hot? That is often what first comes to mind for a lot of people and what the media often portray. My younger self also had this perception until I discovered I was perimenopausal and realised that was far from the reality I was experiencing.
I don’t remember the exact age I was when I became perimenopausal. At first the changes were barely noticeable. I was a bit more tired than usual; I had trouble sleeping; I was experiencing frequent and long-lasting migraines; I felt constantly unwell and ‘not right’ but I couldn’t put my finger on what was actually wrong. It was just a sense that I wasn’t me. At the time, all these symptoms could be explained away with something else that was going on in my life. I had just started a new job, I had just moved house, I had just adopted a Romanian street dog, I’m not a great sleeper anyway and I had always suffered with migraines, so it wasn’t surprising I was feeling this way…right??
As the months went on things became worse. I was experiencing horrific migraines, some that lasted for 5 weeks and disrupted my ability to work. I constantly felt like I was walking through treacle. Even walking the dogs felt like a struggle. I started waking up in the middle of the night completely soaked in a pool of sweat as if someone had just tipped a bucket of water over me. This lasted for months before I went to see my GP. I had blood tests which were clear, and I was sent away.
Things still didn’t improve so another GP visit and I was diagnosed with glandular fever, signed off work and told to rest, but after a period of rest I didn’t feel any better. I went back to the GP and was told that it could take 6 months to resolve. The months came and went, I was still suffering and started to believe this was what being older must feel like and that I just had to live with it.
As time went on I started to develop other symptoms: dry eyes, skin rashes, recurrent periodontal infections. I was having trouble remembering names of people close to me and words for everyday items. I started to feel low and anxious. Again, this wasn’t surprising; I was planning a wedding that was postponed due to Covid, I had moved jobs and was very busy. However, when these settled down, I was still feeling the same. By this time, I had had lots of tests and even paid privately for a second opinion. Everything came back normal; I just couldn’t understand it. Science was telling me I was “normal”, but my body didn’t feel normal. In fact, it was telling me something was very wrong.
Time went on and I suddenly lost confidence in my ability to do my job. It almost seemed to happen overnight, one minute I was setting up a new service and the next I couldn’t even prepare a webinar without having a crisis. I couldn’t complete tasks, not that I didn’t want to, I just couldn’t. I was extremely tearful every day and didn’t enjoy life anymore. I stopped seeing friends (I was either too tired or in pain), I was very irritable, even the littlest thing would send me into a rage. Again, back to the GP, but it was put down to stress, more time off work prescribed, along with anti-depressants. I was already doubting myself and my ability to do a job I knew I could do. I could tell that I was being perceived as not coping and stressed which wasn’t the case as I was trying to cope extremely well with debilitating symptoms, lots of uncertainty of what was happening to me, and the fear that I may be heading to a mental health crisis. I have never been so terrified in my life. I felt incredibly alone and hopeless.
I can’t recall the exact time it all started to make sense to me. One thing I do remember is attending a menopause seminar at a wellbeing conference. I don’t remember who the speaker was, but I want to find her and give her a huge hug. This speaker described their own journey with perimenopause, this speaker was a woman at the top of her game, at senior leadership level, very successful and had worked for years at a prestigious company only to suddenly feel the same as I was feeling. The shocking thing was this woman was encouraged by her employers to reconsider her position in the company when she started suffering with similar symptoms and she ended up leaving her career.
This woman was describing my life and my feelings to the audience! She seemed to totally understand what I had been going through. Somebody else had experienced what I had, and there was a name for it: perimenopause!!
Thus began my mission to make sure that no other woman had to suffer as I did.
Thankfully, with the help of celebrity menopause ambassadors such as Davina McCall and Dr Louise Newson, I was able to do my own research and track my symptoms, and I was well equipped at the next visit to my GP who prescribed HRT without question.
What is the menopause?
So, what is this phenomenon that 51% of the population will inevitably go through?
The literature alludes to four stages of menopause:
Pre-menopause: the time when oestrogen and progesterone work together to regulate menstruation and ovulation.
Perimenopause: A time when hormones are fluctuating, characterised by irregular ovulation and menstruation. During this time the body starts to recognise the decline in oestrogen levels, and this imbalance leads to the onset of menopause symptoms. This can occur several years before the menopause.
Menopause: When menstruation stops and is diagnosable when a person has not had a period for twelve consecutive months. During this time the ovaries are no longer producing eggs and hormones fall. This usually happens between the ages of 45-55 with the average age in the UK being 51.
Post-menopause: The time after ovulation and menstruation have stopped until the end of life.
Not every woman’s menopause story fits neatly into these approximate timelines. Women can experience menopause much earlier. Early menopause occurs between the ages of 40 -45. Menopause under the age of 40 is known as premature ovarian insufficiency (POI) and can sometimes effect people in their teenage years. In addition, some cancer treatments, surgeries such as hysterectomies, autoimmune diseases, and genetics may ‘force’ a person into menopause at a very young age (youngest in the literature is 14!).
My account details someone whose menopause journey started early. Other people will have their own story, their own struggles. The British Menopause Society (BMS, 2022) reports that more than 75% of women experience menopausal symptoms with over a quarter describing their symptoms as severe and a third experiencing long-term symptoms.
There is, however, a huge variety in women’s experiences of the menopause. Some people may experience the symptoms very early; some may experience them late. Some may have mildly fluctuating hormones and be symptom free; whilst others may feel the effects more intensely.
What we do know is that this transition can have a significant impact on those experiencing it. In fact, there are roughly 55 symptoms of the menopause. These can include physical changes such as sore breasts, irregular periods, and fatigue; genitourinary issues such as urinary tract infections and vaginal dryness; vasomotor symptoms which are most recognised with menopause, such as night sweats and hot flushes; cognitive symptoms such as brain fog and memory problems; and emotional symptoms such as mood swings, anxiety, and depression. Despite vasomotor symptoms being synonymous with menopause, many women report experiencing cognitive and emotional symptoms first or report not experiencing the vasomotor symptoms at all.
Research into the menopause is in its infancy. The lack of research, understanding and education in this area means that menopause symptoms are being misdiagnosed or not recognised at all, which can have a detrimental impact on the physical and mental health of all effected.
It doesn’t matter if you are male, female, transgender, or non-binary. Given roughly 51% of the population will inevitably experience this, menopause will impact you in some way, perhaps indirectly.
Let’s talk about menopause…
…not just today, not just around this article, let’s really talk about it. Menopause needs to be a factor we consider as mental health specialists, and we should not be afraid to talk about menopause with clients of any age. The British Menopause society’s vision for menopause care in the UK proposes that all healthcare professionals should have a basic understanding of the menopause and where to signpost women* for support.
It’s no surprise that fluctuating hormones have an impact on mental health. There are oestrogen receptors in almost every organ system in the body, including in the brain. Falling levels of oestrogen directly impact the production of brain chemicals, and can exacerbate mental health symptoms such as irritability, anxiety, and depression. Unfortunately, despite there being an estimated 13 million peri/menopausal women in the UK, education about the menopause is lacking in a significant number of healthcare professionals. Thus, women are often misdiagnosed, given the wrong treatment, or wait many years for a menopause diagnosis.
A podcast I listened to recently described the horrendous journey of one woman who told of being sectioned and receiving Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) instead of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) due to the severity of her depression and suicidal ideation. Another account detailed one woman’s journey of being prescribed a cocktail of SSRI’s and antipsychotic medication to treat her low mood and flattened affect. She was prescribed these for years to no avail until someone recognised that her symptoms could be due to perimenopause and prescribed HRT. Other women I spoke with as part of my research were also diagnosed with depression and prescribed anti-depressants instead of being offered HRT. This goes on despite the NICE guidelines for treating menopause being very clear that antidepressants should not be used as first line treatment for the low mood associated with the perimenopause and menopause.
Symptoms of peri/menopause can be overlooked in women with a current or historical diagnosis of a mental health condition. Symptoms can be conceptualised as a relapse of their mental health condition leaving menopause untreated. This has also been found when women have a long-term condition or a disability. The condition is often the focus of attention, and menopause overlooked and untreated (Behrman and Crockett, 2023).
According to the literature, depression is one of the most common misdiagnoses of the peri/menopause. The symptoms of peri/menopause can overlap with symptoms of depression. However, there are subtle differences that need to be explored. Clinical depression is thought of as a continuous feeling of low mood, whereas menopause-related low mood and anxiety is subject to day-to-day and week-to-week fluctuations: women mention feeling fine one day and floored the next.
The common symptoms in perimenopausal depression are detailed in a questionnaire called the MENO-D (Kulkarni, et al, 2018). In particular, the cognitive symptoms, paranoia and irritability are marked in perimenopausal depression compared to symptoms of major depressive disorders seen in men or younger women (Kulkarni, 2018).
As clinicians our role is to help people understand and make sense of this transition and the impact on their mental health. It is therefore important for health professionals to consider whether women who experience symptoms consistent with depression and anxiety for the first time in their 40s are actually experiencing depression related to the perimenopausal hormone fluctuations. Similarly, women who experience an exacerbation of a previously well-controlled depression may also be experiencing a perimenopausal relapse.
Menopause will undoubtedly mean different things to different people. It may be the happy milestone for some people who have overcome childhood cancer or a welcome relief from a lifetime of chronic pain and suffering with gynaecological problems. It can also be debilitating for some who have struggled to conceive or who want to grow their family and are no longer able. It may impact the identity of non-binary people and transgender men who haven’t received medical intervention. Menopause will also have different cultural meanings and considerations.
What’s important to be aware of is that menopause is a life stage when biological changes are accompanied by broader psychological and social changes. This is the case for other reproductive life stages too, like puberty. But the difference is that the menopause is associated with very negative meanings, especially stereotypes of ageing and decline. No wonder women dread it! All this negative press has an impact on how we view this stage in our life and therefore how we can experience our own menopause. I was dreading this thing that I thought was going to happen when I hit 50, but it was a welcome diagnosis that meant an end to my suffering and an explanation for my symptoms.
At the time of writing, NICE (NICE, 2019) have opened new draft guidance for consultation and are due to release the updated guidance in May 2024**. The WOMGEND SIG have worked closely with the BABCP on submitting comments as part of the consultation process on the draft guidelines. The guidance includes recommending CBT for menopause symptoms including vasomotor symptoms such as hot flushes and night sweats. The NHS have issued guidance which also recommends CBT. This recommendation has caused controversy in the media. Many medical professionals have suggested this may make doctors reluctant to prescribe HRT and make women believe their symptoms are ‘in their head’.
The evidence base for CBT and menopause is still in its infancy and mainly focused on treating the vasomotor symptoms of hot flushes and night sweats. Many studies have shown that CBT can help reduce these vasomotor symptoms of the menopause and help with other symptoms such as sleep disturbances (Hunter & Smith, 2014)
CBT won’t address the hormone depletion that is a biological fact of the perimenopause and menopause. However, it can help with the psychological challenges around the symptoms of the menopause such as night sweats and poor sleep. Or challenges around the transition, such as negative beliefs about the menopause, issues with fertility or identity, and stress. CBT shouldn’t be seen as an equal alternative to HRT. It is an augmentation to HRT. It is crucial we view treatment for menopause holistically just as we would with other health conditions such as diabetes. CBT treatment for menopause should focus on a biopsychosocial approach looking at beliefs, physical symptoms, and lifestyle factors such as diet and exercise.
As CBT therapists we can start to raise awareness and lessen the taboo and stigma of talking about menopause. Ask about hormones in your assessments, consider using screening questionnaires such as MENO-D. Enquire about a client’s history of hormonal related depression such as postnatal depression (PND), premenstrual syndrome (PMS) and premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD). In terms of menopause, we can help clients to understand whether their mental health symptoms are a product of the fluctuating hormones of the perimenopause, or a consequence of other menopause symptoms such as lack of sleep, fatigue, impaired concentration etc.
Menopause is the new hot potato; it is getting the attention it deserves; there have been campaigns to raise awareness and NICE guidelines have been updated with an anticipated release date around May 2024. However, more research is needed in this area. We don’t know enough about experiences from non-western cultures, there hasn’t been much research into the psychological symptoms.
We recognise there are mental health symptoms associated with the peri/menopause. We know they stem from a mixture of fluctuating hormones and the consequence of the menopause transition. As mental health clinicians we need to be skilled in identifying this to enable and empower women to get the right support.
The WOMGEND SIG has a menopause workstream committed to facilitating upskilling of the CBT workforce to enable clinicians to feel confident when assessing and treating people in this transition.
NB*When we refer to women this includes cisgender women, non-binary individuals registered female at birth and transgender men who have not had medical intervention.
** NICE published updated guidance – ‘Menopause: identification and management‘ in November 2024.
Sally Tribe is an accredited CBT Therapist working as a lecturer and academic lead in CBT at the University of East Anglia. Sally is a committee member of the BABCP Women’s Equality & Gender Diversity Special Interest Group (SIG), and part of the SIG’s Menopause Workstream.
References
Behrman, S., & Crockett, C. (2023) Severe mental illness and the perimenopause. British Journal Psychology Bulletin, 1-7
British Menopause Society, (2022). Menopause practice standards.
Hunter MS & Smith M. (2014) Managing hot flushes and night sweats: a cognitive behavioural approach to menopause, Routledge
Kulkarni, J. (2018) Perimenopausal depression – an under recognised entity. Australian Prescriber 41 (6) pp.183-185
Kulkarni, J.; Gavrilidis, E.; Hudaib, A-R.; Bleeker, C.; Worsley, R.; Gulvich, C. (2018) Development and validation of a new rating scale for perimenopausal depression – the Meno-D. Translational Psychiatry 8:123
NICE Guideline (2019) Menopause: diagnosis and management. www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng23/chapter/Recommendations#individualised-care
Further resources
Podcast – Let’s Talk About CBT: Practice Matters – Menopause & CBT. Professor Myra Hunter on why one size doesn’t fit all…
Podcast – Let’s Talk About CBT and the Menopause
