The British Association for Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapies (BABCP) welcomes the opportunity to respond to the Scottish Government’s consultation on the proposed Mental Health Care and Treatment Remedial Order. Access to timely, effective, and evidence-based psychological therapies is essential for good mental health care. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) is a proven treatment for many mental health conditions, and we advocate for its delivery by appropriately trained and accredited therapists.
The proposed changes are a positive step towards improving people’s rights to care and treatment. However, these changes must be supported by enough funding, a well-trained workforce, and clear standards to ensure they work in practice.
Question 1:
Do you have any views on the proposed application rights for patients and their named person?
BABCP believes that mirroring the rights that civil patients already have will ensure that forensic patients and their named persons are not treated differently. We support the extension of application rights in line with the Equality Act and consider that these changes will promote fairness and ensure that forensic patients are not disadvantaged compared to civil patients. Ultimately, we agree that forensic patients should not be disadvantaged in their ability to have specific care, treatment and support needs formally recorded and reviewed.
However, while extending procedural rights is important, the effectiveness of these changes will depend on the availability of appropriate treatment. Recorded matters must translate into access to evidence-based interventions delivered by appropriately qualified practitioners. In particular, patients should have access to NICE-recommended psychological therapies, including Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT), delivered by appropriately qualified practitioners, such as BABCP-accredited CBT therapists.
In addition, where psychological interventions are delivered to patients who are formally detained, it is important that services ensure appropriate safeguards around consent and patient autonomy. Psychological therapies such as CBT are most effective when delivered collaboratively and with informed consent. This highlights the need for a suitably trained workforce, including clinicians who understand the legal and clinical complexities of working in forensic settings and who receive appropriate training and supervision to deliver evidence-based interventions safely and ethically.
Without sufficient workforce capacity, the extension of rights risks creating a gap between entitlement and actual delivery.
Question 2
Do you have any comments on the proposed duties and powers across all parties involved in reviews, including RMOs, MHOs, Scottish Ministers, and the Tribunal?
We welcome the clarification and extension of duties and powers across Responsible Medical Officers (RMOs), Mental Health Officers (MHOs), Scottish Ministers and the Tribunal especially in light of the frameworks intention to strengthen accountability. By ensuring that recorded matters are actively reviewed, delivered and revised – if needed- we believe this has the potential to bring greater fairness to decision-making for forensic patients.
For these provisions to work effectively, however, all parties will require clear operational guidance, shared understanding of expectations, and realistic consideration of service capacity.
Question 3
What, if any, operational challenges do you foresee for services, and how might these be mitigated (e.g. training, guidance, forms)?
BABCP anticipates that the implementation of the proposed changes may present operational challenges. The introduction and review of additional recorded matters will increase administrative and clinical workload in services that are already under significant pressure. There is a risk that clinicians and managers may face increased demands without corresponding increases in workforce or infrastructure.
Of particular concern is workforce capacity within psychological therapies. While NHS Education for Scotland continues to fund CBT training, including for some forensic mental health nurses, social workers and psychologists, our members report that there remain relatively few accredited CBT therapists working within forensic settings. This mirrors challenges in non-forensic services, where access to accredited CBT provision can vary significantly across geographical areas. The result is variability in access and outcomes and a potential “postcode lottery” in the availability of evidence-based therapies.
Without strategic workforce planning and targeted investment in accredited training and supervision pathways, services may struggle to deliver the care specified within recorded matters.
There is also a risk that implementation may become compliance-focused, with emphasis placed on meeting statutory requirements rather than achieving meaningful therapeutic outcomes.
A way to mitigate would be strategic workforce planning, and outcome monitoring e.g through routinely collecting information on patient progress during treatment and investment in talking therapies, including CBT training and supervision pathways within the Scottish healthcare framework.
These duties must be supported by clear guidance and workforce capacity. Without this we believe there is a risk that responsibilities and workload increase without the practical ability to deliver.
Question 4
What impacts – positive or negative – do you anticipate for people with lived experience, families and carers?
BABCP anticipates several positive impacts. People with lived experience, families, carers and named persons may have increased confidence in the system because of clearer rights, safeguards and greater transparency. For carers in particular, clearer information about what care and treatment is expected to be provided may support better understanding and improved relationships with services.
Recorded matters could help ensure that specialist assessments or interventions are explicitly identified, for example in relation to trauma, neurodevelopmental needs or substance use. Increased procedural participation for ‘named persons’ may also reduce the sense of exclusion sometimes reported in forensic settings.
However, there are potential risks. The increased use of recorded matters may raise expectations that services are not currently resourced to meet. Where recorded interventions cannot be delivered in practice, this may lead to frustration or reduced confidence among patients and families. There may also be tensions where treatment preferences expressed by a patient are not supported by clinicians due to public protection considerations. In addition, increased procedural complexity and engagement with tribunal processes may create emotional strain for some individuals.
Careful communication, transparency around consent, adequate support and realistic service planning will be essential to ensure that the reforms enhance rather than undermine trust.
Question 5
In relation to the Interim Equality Impact Assessment, please tell us about any potential impacts you think there may be on protected characteristics?
The Draft Order is likely to have a positive impact on people with protected characteristics. However, equality of rights does not automatically guarantee equality of access. Our members continue to report limited access to CBT across parts of Scotland, with geographical variation affecting the consistency of provision. Individuals in some areas may face longer waits or limited access to accredited therapists. Without addressing these disparities, there is a risk that formal equality in legal rights will not translate into substantive equality in access to evidence-based care.
Question 6
In relation to the Child Rights and Wellbeing Impact Assessment, please tell us about any potential impacts you think there may be on children’s wellbeing?
No comment
Question 7
In relation to the Partial Business Regulatory Impact Assessment, please tell us about any potential impacts you think there may be to particular businesses or organisations?
No comment
Question 8
What do you think about how the changes will be introduced and when they will start?
As mentioned above, BABCP welcomes the proposed extension of application rights for patients and their named persons under the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003, as set out in the draft Remedial Order. We welcome that by November 2026 – which is the proposed date that has been set.
Patients subject to forensic mental health orders will be able to have specific care, treatment and support needs formally recorded in their order, just like civil patients already can.
Question 9
In your view, are there any unintended consequences that could arise as a result of changes to the 2003 Act?
In principle, BABCP supports the intention of the proposed changes and recognises their alignment with human rights principles and procedural fairness. Nevertheless, we are concerned about how the reforms will operate in practice within a system that is already under strain.
Mental health services in Scotland face workforce shortages, long waiting times for psychological therapies and variability in specialist forensic provision across health boards. There are also clear differences in service provision across health boards. Public Health Scotland data on Psychological Therapies Waiting Times show that national standards (90% of patients starting treatment within 18 weeks of referral) are not consistently met.
The Scottish Government’s own progress update notes that there is currently no consistent system in place for collecting and reporting data on key aspects of forensic mental health services.
In this context, increased reliance on recorded matters may inadvertently raise expectations that services cannot fulfil. Without additional investment, there is a risk of inconsistency across geographical areas, increased procedural complexity and added pressure on clinicians. These pressures may detract from therapeutic focus if not carefully managed.
Despite these concerns, we believe the risks can be mitigated through adequate resourcing, clear national guidance and ongoing monitoring.
Question 10
Do you have any other comments on the 2026 Proposed Draft Order?
As noted above, we want to reiterate that extending legal rights must be accompanied by sufficient workforce capacity to deliver evidence-based psychological therapies. Without adequate numbers of trained and accredited practitioners, including CBT therapists, individuals may continue to experience long waits and unmet needs, limiting the practical impact of the reforms.
We would welcome a formal review of the operation and impact of the new orders 12 to 24 months after they have been implemented. This should include evaluation of how recorded matters are being used in practice, consistency across health boards, and whether the changes have led to meaningful improvements for forensic patients.