Section 19: Letters of Guidance/Warning and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
a. A complaint may be resolved through the issue of a Letter of Guidance/Warning where the Panel determines that there is a realistic prospect of a finding that the alleged facts are substantiated (including in cases where the Member admits the allegations), and there is a realistic prospect of a finding that the alleged facts amount to a breach of the Standards, but there is no realistic prospect that the breach will be considered serious enough to require restrictions or conditions of membership, for example, because:
i. the alleged breach of the Standards is minor; and/or
ii. any risk to the public has already been sufficiently addressed by another regulatory body, employer, or other competent body.
b. The purpose of a Letter of Guidance is to provide feedback or advice to assist the Member in maintaining and developing high professional standards. The purpose of a Letter of Warning is to inform the Member that future complaints involving similar conduct may be treated more seriously.
c. The following is a non-exhaustive list of factors that the Panel may take into account when deciding whether to issue a Letter of Guidance or Warning:
i. There have been no, or very minor, adverse consequences or harm resulting from the Member’s conduct;
ii. There is minimal or no risk to the public;
iii. There was an early and genuine acceptance of the concerns by the Member;
iv. Any breach has been remedied and is no longer continuing;
v. The Member has no previous adverse findings and is not the subject of any other current complaints;
vi. The Member has cooperated fully with BABCP;
vii. The Member self-reported the breach of the Standards;
viii. Any reflection, learning, or remediation undertaken by the Member;
ix. Any other relevant mitigating or aggravating factors.
d. The Letter of Guidance or Warning will remain on the Member’s record in accordance with BABCP’s retention policy. It is not a disciplinary sanction but may be taken into account insofar as relevant when determining the appropriate sanction in any future proceedings concerning the Member.
e. Alternatively, where the Panel considers that the Complainant should be involved in the resolution of the matter – for example, to ensure that the Complainant considers the matter to have been resolved fairly, or to strengthen the Member’s insight and learning – it may invite the Complainant and the Member to undertake ADR. ADR is a voluntary process through which the Complainant and the Member seek to reach a mutually acceptable resolution. ADR is only available where the Member admits the allegations, suitable ADR arrangements are available through BABCP, and the Panel considers ADR appropriate and proportionate in the circumstances of the case.
f. The decision to issue a Letter of Guidance/Warning or to undertake ADR will not be published.